Musician Nguyen Van Tuyen was born modern Vietnamese music?

Musician Nguyen Van Tuyen was born modern Vietnamese music?
In front of birth Who Vietnam music? (Wikipedia) published in roundtable GDX, musician Nguyen Van Tuyen about public speaking and presentation of their work in the 1938 presentation, which is nothing new story, but said he was born Vietnam to modern music is also something that we have something to discussion.
First of all would say that this is not about "hard work" for one or deny the merits of composer Nguyen Van Tuyen, but to us there may be legitimate recognition of the role of the artist in history music history.

Wikipedia writes, "But Vietnam really new musical form in 1938 was marked by performances by Nguyen Van Tuyen major presentation of his works in Hanoi". There must be due to events which formed new musical Vietnam? If the form needs a number of songs with a certain quality, the musician Nguyen Van Tuyen really have the quantity and quality of the song needed to form new musical Vietnam? This fact is not answered. He is an advocate of the new enthusiasm for music, but he was not much song and the song he also limited when considered from the perspective of art. Have to wait until the next generation with Dang The Phong, Hoang Quy Hoang Phu, Dzoan Man, Duong Thieu Vietnam Stripping ... new modern music with songs that truly marks its significant development, much work Is that today there are still many fans.

Raises other cases, if the composer Nguyen Van Tuyen no performances and presents his work in 1938, so that new music can not be formed and developed? As we all know the new musical songwriting process go from "composing" said Vietnam's musical based on the songs of the West but at that time people called the movement "words that I beat West" toward the composer and the Vietnamese word called "music reform" or "modern music." It is an objective process of development with the participation of many people and Nguyen Van Tuyen also be one person in the flow, the more there are musicians have composed music before his desk.

So if known composer Nguyen Van Tuyen was the first to compose songs worth starting a musical movement is not right because his work has no value. If the composer called him the earliest the new musical as well as incorrect by Wikipedia writes: "So far most of the critics have recognized the first song of the new musical is all Together Vietnam travel Dinh Nhu Hong war of 1930 ... After composing together to Hong war, there are also many other musicians began composing songs like baby eagle (1935), Artist marches (1936) of Le Yen, flute herd (1935), the willow lake (1936), who through shelf Balls (1937) by Van Chung, Xuan years old (1936) of Le Commerce ".

If we understand the meaning "birth" is the birth of a new one that had never had, or birth was laying the groundwork for the formation and development of a new one, as the case Schubert symphony Dropping (No. 8) that gave birth to the romantic symphony, or the patriarchs with pieces martial yourself "mode" on the Gypsy out that there has never been so giving birth to a martial discipline, the case of composer Nguyen Van Tuyen is not so.

Events that musician Nguyen Van Tuyen created in 1938 is reported to be quite aggressive and the newspaper published a row Today many of modern music, including the new musical version of Nguyen Van Tuyen, this event is considered the official word manifesto Vietnam modern music in the literature of the country, the oil it was formed earlier. It only makes sense in terms of public opinion, not meant for the creation or new birth of music, laid the foundations for the development that without him and without that event, there is no modern music today. By musician Nguyen Van Tuyen if not "birth" new music, it also has to survive and grow and will survive and grow as today. So I think, if known musician Nguyen Van Tuyen was giving birth to new musical Vietnam is inaccurate.